A Sci-Screen event provided a light-hearted backdrop for Centre members to engage the audience of Edinburgh Skeptics in a more serious dialogue about science, its representation and its communication. And what could have been more appropriate than the hilarious ‘Young Frankenstein’ (starring Gene Wilder) in what is the 200th anniversary of the publication of Mary Shelley’s classic novel Frankenstein.
Before the screening, Marie-Anne Robertson, Science Communications Manager for the School of Biological Sciences and Dr Jane Calvert of SynthSys and Science, Technology and Innovation Studies, provided an introduction to media monsters and the necessity for human connectivity respectively.
Throughout the media, literature and film, scientists fall into wearingly familiar stereotypes. Whether it is the hapless scientist losing control of their discovery or the mad scientist hell-bent on global domination – they all tell a familiar tale, and reveal a very important lesson.
In Young Frankenstein an angry mob of villagers circle Dr Frankenstein’s castle; they are not only furious about the creation of the monster but also deeply suspicious of the doctor’s motives.
But look closely and you see this is not a fear of science itself. What really troubles the villagers is power. When ordinary people feel they have little control over new breakthroughs, or the people who may exploit them, alarm bells start ringing. If history has taught us anything, then it is that shrinking away from the debate does us no good.
The fallout from major media scandals and contentious issues, such as GM foods and the MMR vaccine, had profound and far-reaching consequences on policy and public attitudes. It was a wakeup call that shook all those responsible for communicating science. Many lessons have been learnt on the importance of two-way communication.
New approaches like synthetic biology require not only skill in explaining the science but willingness to openly tackle concerns about power. Who gets to decide how to use the technology, who regulates it, who gets to exploit it? This is not only the job of journalists, press officers and scientists but also everyone who is involved in funding, regulating, buying and using the products of science. Discussion about the regulation and use of new technologies, including the practical, ethical and moral issues, is as important as communicating the basic science itself.
As Dr Frankenstein learnt, his creation wasn’t the problem, it was his neglect and failure to take responsibility for his creation and the unintended damage that it caused.
Marie-Anne Robertson, Science Communications Manager, School of Biological Sciences
Image: Creatice commons CC0